‘Root cause’ of criminal cases often mental health issues

by Raj Das

Title: The Shortage of Mental Health Providers in the Silver Valley: A Struggle for Individuals Involved in the Criminal Justice System


The shortage of mental health providers in the Silver Valley has significant implications for individuals facing criminal charges as well as victims of crimes. Obtaining mental health services and necessary medications can be a lengthy process for those preparing to face trial. Furthermore, the overcrowding in the county jail exacerbates the stress and disruptions experienced by inmates. This article explores the challenges individuals in the Silver Valley encounter in accessing mental health resources.

Limited Accessibility and the Revolving Door Effect

Due to the overwhelming demand for mental health services compared to available local resources, individuals entering the Shoshone County Court system often have to travel to Coeur d’Alene to find someone to conduct a mental health evaluation. Scott Sergeant, the Shoshone County Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, highlights the troubling pattern of a “revolving door in the criminal justice system.” People affected by mental health crises may receive short-term treatment during their case, but once their legal proceedings conclude, they often stop treatment due to cost or other factors, leading to instability and a higher likelihood of engaging in further criminal activity.

The Role of Support Services

Support services in the Silver Valley play a crucial role in connecting victims to advocacy and mental health resources in the aftermath of violent crimes. The Shoshone County Crisis and Resource Center focuses on guiding survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, stalking, and other violent crimes through the healing process. While the organization provides advocacy services, connecting survivors with licensed therapists or mental health counselors is a challenge due to the limited ratio of counselors to the population.

The Mutual Support Among Mental Health Providers

Despite the strain on local providers, there is a sense of mutual respect and collaboration among mental health professionals in the Silver Valley. Meghann Johnson, the social service manager at Shoshone Medical Center, praises the effective communication and cooperation between departments. This positive collaboration allows counselors to rely on one another when faced with an urgent need for crisis care. The agencies in the Silver Valley work together to support families in crisis and ensure that both parents and children receive the necessary care.


The shortage of mental health providers in the Silver Valley negatively impacts individuals involved in the criminal justice system as well as victims of crimes. The inability to access timely mental health services and the lack of ongoing support contribute to the revolving door effect in the criminal justice system. Support services, while valuable, face their own challenges in providing adequate resources to survivors. Despite these obstacles, the collaborative efforts and mutual support among mental health providers in the Silver Valley offer hope for bridging the gap between the demand and availability of mental health resources.

You may also like